null
Toggle menu
216.464.2424
  • Gift Certificate
  • LoginorSign Up
  • 0
PlayMatters Toys
×
×

    Shop By Category

  • Active Play
  • Arts & Crafts
  • Books & Activity Books
  • Building & Construction
  • Dolls & Accessories
  • Dress Up
  • Games
  • Greeting Cards
  • Holiday
  • Imaginative Play
  • Infant
  • Music
  • Novelty
  • Plush Toys
    • Plush Toys
    • Puppets
  • Puzzles
  • Remote Control
  • Robotics
  • Room Decor
  • STEM
  • Toddler Toys
  • Trains
  • Vehicles
  • Sale
  • Catalog
  • Shop by Age
    • Shop by Age
    • Baby & Toddler
    • Little Kids
    • Big Kids
    • Tweens & Teens
      • Tween & Teen
    • Families & Adults
      • Family & Adult Games
      • Family & Adult Puzzles
  • Bonus
    • Bonus
    • Staff Picks
      • Barb's Favorites
      • Chris's Favorites
      • Mary's Favorites
      • Xavier's Favorites
  • Shop By Brand

  • JellyCat
  • Douglas
  • LEGO
  • Ravensburger
  • Creative Education of Canada
  • EDC Publishing
  • Schleich
  • Schylling
  • Peaceable Kingdom
  • Usbourne Books
  • OOLY
  • The Toy Network
  • Tonies
  • Calico Critters
  • Corolle
  • Bruder Toys
  • Crocodile Creek
  • Thames & Kosmos
  • Hape
  • DJECO
  • Springbok
  • MindWare
  • Brio
  • Eeboo
  • US Toy Company
  • Fat Brain Toys
  • Hauck
  • iScream
  • Creativity for Kids
  • Mary Meyer Corp
  • Gund
  • Faber-Castell
  • Juratoys
  • Klutz
  • Micro Kickboard
  • Toysmith
  • Folkmanis
  • Pokemon
  • Squishable
  • Crazy Aaron's Puttyworld
  • Premier Kites
  • Playmobil
  • Papo
  • Charm It
  • Smart Toys & Games
  • Earth Grown Kid Doughs
  • Kidoozie
  • The Puppet Company
  • ACD Distribution
  • Melissa & Doug
  • Mukikim
  • PlayMonster
  • Thin Air Brands
  • Tangle Creations
  • bcmini
  • Bright Stripes
  • Waboba
  • Watchitude
  • Play Visions
  • Peter Pauper Press
  • Asmodee
  • Epoch games
  • Bababoo
  • HABA
  • Little Golden Book
  • Spin Master
  • mojo
  • Scentco Inc.
  • Dope Slimes LLC
  • Manhattan Toy
  • Keycraft Global
  • Magna Tiles
  • PlanToys
  • Indestructible
  • Cottage Door Press
  • Hotaling Imports
  • Little Kids Inc.
  • Plus-Plus
  • Wow Toys
  • Incredible Group
  • Santoki
  • Amahi
  • Continuum Games
  • Ditty Bird Books
  • ThinkFun
  • Buddy and Barney
  • Dam
  • Chooseco
  • Harper Collins
  • Hot Wheels
  • Make It Real
  • Sentosphere
  • Wise Elk
  • Blue Orange
  • Flybar
  • Klee Kids
  • Zorbitz
  • Anirollz
  • Blank Tag Co.
  • Gamewright
  • View all Brands
  • Content Pages

  • Shop by Age
    • Shop by Age
    • Baby & Toddler
    • Little Kids
    • Big Kids
    • Tweens & Teens
    • Families & Adults
  • Summer Catalog
    • Summer Catalog
    • Join Our Mailing List
  • Staff Picks
    • Staff Picks
    • Barb's Favorites
    • Mary's Favorites
    • Chris's Favorites
    • Xavier's Favorites
  • Contact
  • About
    • About
    • Blog
    • Refunds & Shipping
    • Privacy Policy
    • Frequently Asked Questions
  • User Navigation

  • Gift Certificates
  • LoginorSign Up
  • Connect with Us

×
  • Shop by Age
    • Shop by Age
    • Baby & Toddler
    • Little Kids
    • Big Kids
    • Tweens & Teens
    • Families & Adults
  • Summer Catalog
    • Summer Catalog
    • Join Our Mailing List
  • Staff Picks
    • Staff Picks
    • Barb's Favorites
    • Mary's Favorites
    • Chris's Favorites
    • Xavier's Favorites
  • Contact
  • About
    • About
    • Blog
    • Refunds & Shipping
    • Privacy Policy
    • Frequently Asked Questions

Shop By Category

  • Active Play
  • Arts & Crafts
  • Books & Activity Books
  • Building & Construction
  • Dolls & Accessories
  • Dress Up
  • Games
  • Greeting Cards
  • Holiday
  • Imaginative Play
  • Infant
  • Music
  • Novelty
  • Plush Toys
    • Puppets
  • Puzzles
  • Remote Control
  • Robotics
  • Room Decor
  • STEM
  • Toddler Toys
  • Trains
  • Vehicles
  • Sale
  • Catalog
  • Shop by Age
    • Baby & Toddler
    • Little Kids
    • Big Kids
    • Tweens & Teens
      • Tween & Teen
    • Families & Adults
      • Family & Adult Games
      • Family & Adult Puzzles
  • Bonus
    • Staff Picks
      • Barb's Favorites
      • Chris's Favorites
      • Mary's Favorites
      • Xavier's Favorites

Shop By Brand

  • JellyCat
  • Douglas
  • LEGO
  • Ravensburger
  • Creative Education of Canada
  • EDC Publishing
  • Schleich
  • Schylling
  • Peaceable Kingdom
  • Usbourne Books
  • View all Brands

Halloween Jellycat

Come shop the creepiest, cutest little fall critters. Selection changes daily, shop in store or call for the best selection.

Shop All Jellycat

We're Hiring!

Here, having fun is a mandatory requirement. Join us late afternoons and/or weekends.

Apply Today!

Wigglitz Take Over!

These tiny 3D printed toys bend and flex to maximize your fidgety fun. Visit in store for huge selection.

Shop Wigglitz

PlayMatters Toys Wins Again

Best local, independent store to buy toys, games & learning products’ in 2025 Parent Choice Awards

Read Article

Featured Products

3 In 1 Portable Sprinkler 3 In 1 Portable Sprinkler 3 In 1 Portable Sprinkler 3 In 1 Portable Sprinkler
Quick view Details

Little Kids Inc.

|

sku: 210000010593

3 In 1 Portable Sprinkler

MSRP:
Now: $24.99
Add to Cart

Current Top Sellers

Nice Ice Baby Small Nice Cube NeeDoh - Nice Ice Baby (assorted colors) 1 Nice Ice Baby Small Nice Cube NeeDoh - Nice Ice Baby (assorted colors) 1
Quick view Details

Schylling

|

sku: 210000013611

Nice Ice Baby Small Nice Cube

MSRP:
Now: $3.99
Add to Cart
Iceberg Large Nice Cube NeeDoh Nice Berg 1 Iceberg Large Nice Cube NeeDoh Nice Berg 1
Quick view Details

Schylling

|

sku: 210000013612

Iceberg Large Nice Cube

MSRP:
Now: $12.99
Add to Cart
Play Tab Activity Square Set 1 PlayTab Tiles Set 1 1 Play Tab Activity Square Set 1 PlayTab Tiles Set 1 1
Quick view Details

Fat Brain Toys

|

sku: 210000013164

Play Tab Activity Square Set 1

MSRP:
Now: $19.99
Add to Cart
Play Tab Activity Square Set 2 PlayTab Tiles Set 2 1 Play Tab Activity Square Set 2 PlayTab Tiles Set 2 1
Quick view Details

Fat Brain Toys

|

sku: 210000013165

Play Tab Activity Square Set 2

MSRP:
Now: $19.99
Add to Cart
Micro Fidgetz Micro Fidgetz Micro Fidgetz Micro Fidgetz
Quick view Details

One For Fun

|

sku: 210000011068

Micro Fidgetz

MSRP:
Now: $4.99
Add to Cart
Play Tab Activity Square Set 4 PlayTab Tiles Set 4 1 Play Tab Activity Square Set 4 PlayTab Tiles Set 4 1
Quick view Details

Fat Brain Toys

|

sku: 210000013167

Play Tab Activity Square Set 4

MSRP:
Now: $19.99
Add to Cart
Air Toobz 1 Air Toobz 1 Air Toobz 1 Air Toobz 1
Quick view Details

Fat Brain Toys

|

sku: 210000009370

Air Toobz

MSRP:
Now: $172.99
Add to Cart
Nice Cube Nee-Doh (assorted) 1 Nice Cube Nee-Doh (assorted) 5 Nice Cube Nee-Doh (assorted) 1 Nice Cube Nee-Doh (assorted) 5
Quick view Details

Schylling

|

sku: 210000008412

Nice Cube Nee Doh

MSRP:
Now: $5.99
Add to Cart

Hours:
Monday - Friday: 10 am to 6 pm
Saturday: 9:30 am to 5:30 pm  |   Sunday: 11 am to 4 pm

New Products

Quick view Details

Master Toys

|

sku: 210000016903

Surfer Hank Yeti

MSRP:
Now: $24.99
Add to Cart
Quick view Details

Master Toys

|

sku: 210000016901

Light Up Pop It Game

MSRP:
Now: $15.99
Add to Cart
Leola Bear Medium Leola Bear Medium Leola Bear Medium Leola Bear Medium
Quick view Details

JellyCat

|

sku: 210000016897

Leola Bear Medium

MSRP:
Now: $35.00
Add to Cart
Diary: Lock & Key: Be Kind Diary 1 Diary: Lock & Key: Be Kind Diary 2 Diary: Lock & Key: Be Kind Diary 1 Diary: Lock & Key: Be Kind Diary 2
Quick view Details

MindWare

|

sku: 210000016890

Diary Lock & Key Be Kind Diary

MSRP:
Now: $12.99
Add to Cart
Quick view Details

ACD Distribution

|

sku: 210000016889

Pokemon Holiday Calendar 2025

MSRP:
Now: $59.99
Add to Cart
Nano-Mals Interactive Pets 1 Nano-Mals Interactive Pets 2 Nano-Mals Interactive Pets 1 Nano-Mals Interactive Pets 2
Quick view Details

ACD Distribution

|

sku: 210000016852

Nanomals Interactive Pet

MSRP:
Now: $29.99
Add to Cart
Die-cast Car Transporter 1 Die-cast Car Transporter 2 Die-cast Car Transporter 1 Die-cast Car Transporter 2
Quick view Details

The Toy Network

|

sku: 210000016848

T13 Die Cast Car Transporter

MSRP:
Now: $29.99
Add to Cart
24\" Giant Sparkle Rubber Chicken 1 24\" Giant Sparkle Rubber Chicken 1
Quick view Details

The Toy Network

|

sku: 210000016847

Giant Sparkle Rubber Chicken

MSRP:
Now: $34.99
Add to Cart

Recent Blog Posts

Despite Uncertainty, PlayMatters Continues to Find a Way to Play

May 18th 2025

Despite Uncertainty, PlayMatters Continues to Find a Way to Play
Spring Coupon Expires May 4, 2025

Apr 27th 2025

Spring Coupon Expires May 4, 2025
Small Business Saturday Free Giveaway

Nov 17th 2024

Small Business Saturday Free Giveaway
Join in Toys for Tots 2024

Nov 11th 2024

Join in Toys for Tots 2024
Girl Scout Cookies Pop Up Booth!!

Mar 7th 2024

Girl Scout Cookies Pop Up Booth!!
​Small Business Saturday-Free Nee Doh Giveaway

Nov 24th 2023

​Small Business Saturday-Free Nee Doh Giveaway
×

Join Our Mailing List for special offers!


Get PLAYmatters toy, gift & game ideas, plus coupons. We're gentle on your inbox, environmentally friendly, and we never share your data.

Contact Us

30789 Pinetree Rd.
Pepper Pike, OH 44124

Account

  • Gift Certificates
  • Wishlist
  • Login or Sign Up
  • Shipping & Returns

Navigate

  • Shop by Age
  • Summer Catalog
  • Staff Picks
  • Contact
  • About

Recent Blog Posts

  • Despite Uncertainty, PlayMatters Continues to Find a Way to Play
  • Spring Coupon Expires May 4, 2025
  • Small Business Saturday Free Giveaway
  • Join in Toys for Tots 2024
  • Girl Scout Cookies Pop Up Booth!!

Connect with Us

  • © PlayMatters Toys |
  • Sitemap |
  • Premium BigCommerce Theme by Lone Star Templates